Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (2024)

Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (1)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (2)

Trey Wingo

stated on June 21, 2021 in a tweet:

A 9-0 Supreme Court ruling is very rare.

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (3)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (4)
  • Supreme Court
  • Trey Wingo

By Louis JacobsonJune 23, 2021

If Your Time is short

• Despite a widespread belief that the Supreme Court is hopelessly divided along partisan lines, 9-0 rulings aren’t rare at all. Since at least 2008, they’ve usually accounted for a plurality of rulings, and they never fell below 36% of all rulings during that period.

• While 5-4 rulings tend to attract more public and media attention, they have consistently trailed 9-0 rulings in frequency.

See the sources for this fact-check

In one of the final decisions of its current term, the Supreme Court unanimously ruled against the National Collegiate Athletic Association in a closely watched case, concluding that the NCAA could not prevent certain payments to college athletes, thus putting the longstanding amateur model of college sports in jeopardy.

After the ruling was announced, Trey Wingo, a former ESPN host and commentator, sent a tweet that sought to encapsulate how stunning the Supreme Court’s 9-0 decision was.

"A 9-0 Supreme Court ruling is the equivalent of finding a unicorn and a Yeti at the same time under a rainbow with a pot of gold and they’re both speaking 3 languages," Wingo tweeted on June 21.

A 9-0 Supreme Court ruling is the equivalent of finding a unicorn and a Yeti at the same time under a rainbow with a pot of gold and they’re both speaking 3 languages https://t.co/o9LGdOcE1C

— trey wingo (@wingoz) June 21, 2021

That’s quite a way to say that something is "rare." But the reality is the opposite: 9-0 rulings are the most common types of Supreme Court rulings, year after year. While 5-4 rulings attract the most attention from the public and the media, there’s a good chance that a larger number of cases you never heard about were decided on a unanimous basis.

Wingo’s tweet "reflects the common misperception that the court is hopelessly split," said Ilya Shapiro, a vice president of the libertarian Cato Institute and a Supreme Court watcher. "The cases that make the front pages, or the digital-era equivalent, aren’t the 9-0 rulings on bankruptcy law or personal jurisdiction but rather the culture-war controversies that do tend to be 5-4."

Wingo did not respond to an inquiry via Twitter.

Looking at the data

Experts told us that the most complete data on Supreme Court decisions is tallied by the publication SCOTUSBlog. We looked at their data since 2008 for 9-0 rulings, 5-4 rulings, and other ruling combinations.

Between 2008 and 2019, which is the last year for which SCOTUSBlog has published the data, the percentage of all Supreme Court rulings that were 9-0 ranged from a low of 36% and a high of 66%. (Technical note: These figures include rulings in which justices voted with the majority but may have written their own opinions to explain their reasoning.)

By contrast, the percentage of 5-4 rulings ranged from 5% and 29%. And the percentage of rulings with any other numerical breakdown ranged from 20% to 51%.

In the term that ran from the fall of 2018 to the summer of 2019, the breakdown was 36% 9-0 rulings, 21% 5-4 rulings, and 43% any other ruling.

Featured Fact-check

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (6)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (7)

Facebook posts

stated on April 25, 2024 in a Facebook post

As of April 24, “there was active military in 360 U.S. cities awaiting a Supreme Court announcement ‘that will rock the world’ and trigger cabal deep state planned protests.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (8)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (9)

Put a different way, in most years, the share of 9-0 rulings amounted to a plurality. Even in the years when it wasn’t a plurality, 9-0 rulings accounted for 30% to 40% of decisions.

Why there’s a misconception

Legal experts said Wingo’s misconception is understandable.

"The close splits may be fewer, but they are more often in high-profile cases with a broader impact and that affect the rights of more people," said Sarah E. Turberville, director of the Constitution Project at the Project On Government Oversight.

Indeed, there’s a bit of circular logic feeding the misunderstanding. "High-profile cases tend to be high-profile precisely because they are about divisive issues such as abortion, same-sex marriage, affirmative action, and church-state relations," said Eugene Volokh, a law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles.

Volokh added that the 9-0 decision in the case involving the NCAA may have been surprising because it was a high-profile issue but one on which there was not a lot of legal disagreement.

"It involved a question that’s of practical interest to the public, but not because it involved some deeply felt legal divide," he said. "It’s thus unsurprising that the justices agreed on the legal question."

Another high-profile 9-0 decision from June was Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, which held that Philadelphia violated constitutionally protected religious freedom when it refused to contract with Catholic Social Services for foster care services unless the group agreed to certify same-sex couples as foster parents.

The Fulton case offers another example that even high-profile rulings do not necessarily fall "on clear partisan lines," said Anthony Marcum, a resident fellow at the R Street Institute, a right-of-center think tank.

Our ruling

Wingo said, "A 9-0 Supreme Court ruling is the equivalent of finding a unicorn and a Yeti at the same time under a rainbow with a pot of gold and they’re both speaking 3 languages."

In truth, 9-0 rulings aren’t rare at all. In the past decade, they accounted for a plurality of rulings and never fell below 36% of all rulings. They are more common than 5-4 rulings.

Experts said it’s easy to understand why this misperception is so common, since many of the 9-0 rulings are on technical cases that don’t receive as much attention as the more dramatic 5-4 splits.

We rate the statement False.

Read About Our Process

The Principles of the Truth-O-Meter

Our Sources

Trey Wingo, tweet, June 21, 2021

SCOTUSBlog, data on unanimity, accessed June 22, 2021

SCOTUSBlog, data on 5-4 decisions, accessed June 22, 2021

New York Times, "Supreme Court Backs Payments to Student-Athletes in N.C.A.A. Case," June 21, 2021

Washington Post, "Those 5-to-4 decisions on the Supreme Court? 9 to 0 is far more common," June 28, 2018

Email interview with Kermit Roosevelt, law professor at the University of Pennsylvania, June 22, 2021

Email interview with Ilya Shapiro, a vice president of the Cato Institute, June 22, 2021

Email interview with Sarah E. Turberville, director of the Constitution Project at the Project On Government Oversight, June 22, 2021

Email interview with Anthony Marcum, resident fellow at the R Street Institute, June 22, 2021

Email interview with Eugene Volokh, law professor at UCLA, June 22, 2021

Email interview with Timothy Zick, law professor at the College of William & Mary, June 22, 2021

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Louis Jacobson

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (10)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (11)

Kamala Harris

stated on May 1, 2024 in a speech:

In his Time magazine interview, Donald Trump “said states have the right to monitor pregnant women to enforce these bans, and states have the right to punish pregnant women for seeking out abortion care.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (12)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (13)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (18)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (19)

Joe Biden

stated on April 26, 2024 in an interview with Howard Stern:

Says he “got arrested” while protesting in favor of desegregation.

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (20)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (21)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (22)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (23)

Mike Johnson

stated on April 24, 2024 in an interview with CNN:

Said Columbia University has told students, “Well, if you’re Jewish, maybe you do want to stay home.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (24)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (25)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (26)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (27)

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

stated on March 31, 2024 in a post on X:

"The much-trumpeted job growth in the last year was ENTIRELY part-time jobs."

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (28)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (29)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (30)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (31)

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

stated on April 21, 2024 in a post on X:

“Congress prohibits the NIH from researching the cause of mass shootings.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (32)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (33)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (34)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (35)

Marco Rubio

stated on April 11, 2024 in an interview with Fox News:

“It's very misleading when (President Biden) says (inflation) used to be at 9%. This is compounding. It’s not like it went down from 9% to 3%. This is building month after month. The better way to think about it is that it’s 18%, 19% over the last three years."

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (36)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (37)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (38)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (39)

Donald Trump

stated on April 8, 2024 in a video posted on Truth Social:

"All legal scholars, both sides, wanted, and in fact demanded” that Roe v. Wade be overturned.

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (40)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (41)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (42)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (43)

Joe Biden

stated on April 8, 2024 in a Facebook post:

“Support for Roe is higher today in America than it has ever been."

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (44)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (45)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (50)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (51)

Nancy Mace

stated on March 30, 2024 in a post on X:

“Since Joe Biden took office, crime has skyrocketed across our country.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (52)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (53)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (54)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (55)

Donna Brazile

stated on March 24, 2024 in remarks on ABC's "This Week":

The current Congress is “the least productive in our lifetime.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (56)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (57)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (58)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (59)

X posts

stated on March 22, 2024 in an X post:

A March 7 U.S. security alert … means the U.S. was “behind this gruesome terror attack on Russian civilians.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (60)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (61)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (62)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (63)

J.D. Vance

stated on March 14, 2024 in an interview with Fox News:

Says “100% of net job creation under the Biden administration has gone to the foreign-born.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (64)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (65)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (66)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (67)

Nicole Shanahan

stated on March 26, 2024 in her vice presidential announcement speech:

If elected, “I will be the youngest vice president in American history.”

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (68)

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (69)

Despite popular misconception, Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare

  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (70)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (71)

    Facebook posts

    stated on May 1, 2024 in una publicación en Facebook:

    "Estudiantes de la Universidad de Harvard cambiaron la bandera estadounidense por la de Palestina".

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (72)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (73)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (74)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (75)

    Facebook posts

    stated on April 29, 2024 in a Facebook post:

    An executive order proves President Joe Biden “isn’t real and isn’t president.”

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (76)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (77)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (78)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (79)

    Facebook posts

    stated on May 1, 2024 in a Facebook post:

    Video shows Dr. Mehmet Oz promoting his “exclusive pills” to lose weight.

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (80)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (81)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (82)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (83)

    Facebook posts

    stated on May 1, 2024 in a Facebook post:

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (84)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (85)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (86)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (87)

    Facebook posts

    stated on April 30, 2024 in a Facebook post:

    Hacker Hamza Bendelladj was executed.

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (88)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (89)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (90)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (91)

    Threads posts

    stated on May 1, 2024 in a Threads post:

    “Donald Trump wants to build an ‘iron dome’ at the border of our country to ‘defend us’ from Canada.”

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (92)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (93)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (94)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (95)

    Facebook posts

    stated on April 30, 2024 in a Facebook reel:

    Video shows “protesters at Harvard replace American flag with Palestinian flag.”

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (96)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (97)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (98)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (99)

    Joe Biden

    stated on May 1, 2024 in a campaign event:

    Former President Donald Trump told Time magazine that “states should monitor women’s pregnancies and prosecute those who violate abortion bans.”

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (100)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (101)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (102)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (103)

    Donald Trump

    stated on May 2, 2024 in remarks to reporters:

    “I’m not allowed to testify” because of a gag order.

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (104)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (105)
  • Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (106)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (107)

    Viral image

    stated on April 27, 2024 in a Facebook post:

    Four people “tested positive” after a Texas pool was “infected with AIDS.”

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (108)

    Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (109)

Load more

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up

Supreme Court 9-0 rulings aren’t that rare (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gregorio Kreiger

Last Updated:

Views: 5707

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gregorio Kreiger

Birthday: 1994-12-18

Address: 89212 Tracey Ramp, Sunside, MT 08453-0951

Phone: +9014805370218

Job: Customer Designer

Hobby: Mountain biking, Orienteering, Hiking, Sewing, Backpacking, Mushroom hunting, Backpacking

Introduction: My name is Gregorio Kreiger, I am a tender, brainy, enthusiastic, combative, agreeable, gentle, gentle person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.